166 replies to this topic

[chatanga1]

HSD, on 29 October 2009 - 07:08 PM, said:

If sikhs today have no link to their sikh ancestors, how does the Gita act as a Gurbani for an earlier time? If so, why bother with the Gita? Surely Gurbani is all you need then.

You're right about not bothering with the gita. we only need gurbani. If we didnt Guru would have said. Gita is from times gone by. If we need the Gita in Kalyug, then would we have needed Guru Nanak, or could we have just kept Sri Krishan Bhagwaan from the previous yug?

Edited by chatanga1, 29 October 2009 - 08:08 PM.

[N30 S!NGH]

This thread is been closed since it has taken many turns and lot of stuff has been off-topics.

Both parties please pm me questions for proper discussion, I will create a moderated topic where posts gets manually approved by sevadars, in that thread. Harjas kaur will given an opportunity first to provide questions/claims not because she is on trial but lady first. I think senstive topic like this were emotions are high, moderated topic will be the best. That way we can enforce no personal attacks are over-looked and there are no off-topics.

PM me if both parties are interested...!!