Manbir singh ji
It was nice to listen to wonderful kirtan.
I saw that you belong to Gurmat Gian missionary college. I have a question.
Why does this college propagate against Bani of Dasam pita? It is in the forefront
supporting blasphemy of Ragi Darshan. Its parcharaks like Inder Ghagha, Sarabjit Dhundha,
Sukhwinder dadhehr, Sabhra spew venom against established sikh traditions.
Thanks singh2 for listening to the Kirtan by Gurmat Gian Group and finding it 'Wonderful'. The real Wonder lies in the Bani that we Sikhs have the privilege of considering as our Guru, as our Guide, as our Protector and our sole ray of hope whenever we find ourselves in some crisis or some insurmountable problem.
Why all this ??
Why do we consider Bani of Sri Guru Granth Sabib Ji as our sole Guru?
It is Not an "established sikh tradition" to consider the Bani of Sri Guru Granth Sabib ji as our Guru. No, it is not because of some 'tradition' that we consider SGGS as our Guru. The Fact is that we The Sikhs consider Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji as our Guru because our 10th Master Sri Guru Gobind Singh ji gave us an 'Order' that after Him Only Bani of Sri Guru Granth Sahib ji is our Guru. Am I wrong?
Now, for we Sikhs there ceases to be any differentiation were the Bani of SGGS is concerned. The teachings of SGGS ji is a collective wisdom of All our Ten Gurus.
When Dasam pita Himself ordered us to consider the Bani of SGGS ji as our GURU why should we waste our precious time of this jeevan finding guidance from anything other than SGGS ji ?
Do we find the Bani of SGGS not sufficient?
Have we reached a stage where Bani of SGGS is not answering our thirst of Spiritual knowledge and we need to find something more!!
No, at least for me I have a long way to go and I feel one lifetime is not enough to go through All the teachings of SGGS.
Why should some of us get the feeling of being more intelligent than our 'Dasam pita' is beyond my comprehension !!!
Well, I can not answer on behalf of parcharaks like Inder Ghagha, Sarabjit Dhundha, Sukhwinder dadhehr, Sabhra etc. All of them are surely much more enlightened persons and can answer to queries themselves.
One thing I surely fail to understand and that is, why some of our brothers are anxious to replace the sovereignty of Sri Guru Granth Shib ji !!
And let us not cloud our sense of judgement with cliques like “established sikh traditions”. Anything you keep doing for a period of time gets the label of “established traditions”. Hinduism, Islam and all other traditional religions are suffering from the burden of “established traditions”.
Bhul CHuk Maaf