Jump to content

Types of Dand (Punishment)


Recommended Posts

Dhan Guru Nanak Ji,

There is Pitr Dand, Daivik Dand and Rishi Dand.

The meaning of dand is to punish or reprimand, normally for transgressing a law. Dand also means rod, which can symbolise power and sovereignty as a staff or sceptre - that can be used to mete out punishments. The three punishments above, may refer to three innate (not man made) laws in the universe that when opposed or flaunted will cause a 'danda' to fall on the transgressor's head. I believe they are related to the three Rna's(debts) of the same name. The first debt is to the ancestors. To fulfill this debt you must continue the family lineage - procreate, if you do not have children Pitr dand will be visited upon you and you will become dried up and miserable. The next debt is to nature or the earth we live on. If we do not live frugally, consume more than we need or hoard wealth and abuse our Mother Earth the Daivik Dand will occur. Which would be natural disasters, illness and disease in the body. Rishi Rna is the obligation we owe to our teachers, of whatever Dharam, if we do not follow the wise teachings of the enlightened Saints our buddhi/understanding will become diseased - Rishi Danda and as they say; Vinash Kale Vipreet Buddhi.

On a more intrinsic level all mental actions that are incorrect and against harmonious relations become the seeds of Rishi dand.

All emotional feelings that are incorrect cause Pitr dand.

And incorrect bodily acts cause Daivik dand.

If you really want to go deep into it we could link in Karma theory and how some forms of Dand are instantaneous or delayed akin to Sanchita, Prarabdha and Vartmaan karams. We could also find a way to destroy the seeds of future dand by doing appropriate actions now. Collectively amd individually.

So danda is the inevitable result of transgressing a law in the Universe, it is impersonal (hand in fire=burn) and unseen. But strictly speaking the Law is not transgressed only an effect follows from a cause, it can be experienced as being transgressed if a person accepts that he must self develop: then, certain actions set up causes and effects that are harmful for self development. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dhan Guru Nanak Ji,

There is Pitr Dand, Daivik Dand and Rishi Dand.

The meaning of dand is to punish or reprimand, normally for transgressing a law. Dand also means rod, which can symbolise power and sovereignty as a staff or sceptre - that can be used to mete out punishments. The three punishments above, may refer to three innate (not man made) laws in the universe that when opposed or flaunted will cause a 'danda' to fall on the transgressor's head. I believe they are related to the three Rna's(debts) of the same name. The first debt is to the ancestors. To fulfill this debt you must continue the family lineage - procreate, if you do not have children Pitr dand will be visited upon you and you will become dried up and miserable. The next debt is to nature or the earth we live on. If we do not live frugally, consume more than we need or hoard wealth and abuse our Mother Earth the Daivik Dand will occur. Which would be natural disasters, illness and disease in the body. Rishi Rna is the obligation we owe to our teachers, of whatever Dharam, if we do not follow the wise teachings of the enlightened Saints our buddhi/understanding will become diseased - Rishi Danda and as they say; Vinash Kale Vipreet Buddhi.

On a more intrinsic level all mental actions that are incorrect and against harmonious relations become the seeds of Rishi dand.

All emotional feelings that are incorrect cause Pitr dand.

And incorrect bodily acts cause Daivik dand.

If you really want to go deep into it we could link in Karma theory and how some forms of Dand are instantaneous or delayed akin to Sanchita, Prarabdha and Vartmaan karams. We could also find a way to destroy the seeds of future dand by doing appropriate actions now. Collectively amd individually.

So danda is the inevitable result of transgressing a law in the Universe, it is impersonal (hand in fire=burn) and unseen. But strictly speaking the Law is not transgressed only an effect follows from a cause, it can be experienced as being transgressed if a person accepts that he must self develop: then, certain actions set up causes and effects that are harmful for self development. 

​Bro, what about Raaj dand and Dev dand? Do they exist too?

Bhul chuk maaf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dhan Guru Nanak Ji

The word Daivik means from or of the Devas, it was believed that certain Devas influenced the destiny of Humans and through this influence the fate of a person was determined. So the word Daiva came to mean 'fate'. Thus Daivik dand came to mean general 'fate' and accidents of nature and negative social effects. This would include Raaj dand which is any punishment by the state/government for example a court case. Any external authority imposing restriction/anxiety upon an individual falls under Daivik dand, Pitr dand is more in the past i.e. inherited traits and Rishi dand in the future. Pitri dand is not just about procreation but also it is your inherited qualities and bodily form, if your ancestors misbehaved the punishment will be visited upon you: their progeny, this is another meaning of Pitri dand. Rishi dand is also related to Bhagti and Naam Jaap, in the 'future' a person who did not put effort into Bhagti will suffer from Rishi dand. Pitri and Rishi dand are unseen/atemporal forms of punishment whereas Daivik dand is seen/temporal punishment. Daivik dand can be financial difficulties, court cases, disrespect, depression, loneliness, oppression, war, starvation, natural disasters, seperation of loved ones etc. Rishi or Pitri punishments are different to the above class. For example through Pitri dand you may have a bent leg even though you may have honor in the world and much money but you still are stuck with having a bent leg.

Dev dand does not exist as Devas are beneficent Beings and help Humans. What Dev dand refers to is imaginary gods that people started praying to and through force of habit created an independent thoughtform. The Brahmins started this trick of praying and worshiping imaginary gods, they made people do convoluted poojas to make money from them and when they did not do the pooja in a correct way the brahmins said that such a person would get dev dand.

Dhan Guru Nanak Ji

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dhan Guru Nanak Ji

The word Daivik means from or of the Devas, it was believed that certain Devas influenced the destiny of Humans and through this influence the fate of a person was determined. So the word Daiva came to mean 'fate'. Thus Daivik dand came to mean general 'fate' and accidents of nature and negative social effects. This would include Raaj dand which is any punishment by the state/government for example a court case. Any external authority imposing restriction/anxiety upon an individual falls under Daivik dand, Pitr dand is more in the past i.e. inherited traits and Rishi dand in the future. Pitri dand is not just about procreation but also it is your inherited qualities and bodily form, if your ancestors misbehaved the punishment will be visited upon you: their progeny, this is another meaning of Pitri dand. Rishi dand is also related to Bhagti and Naam Jaap, in the 'future' a person who did not put effort into Bhagti will suffer from Rishi dand. Pitri and Rishi dand are unseen/atemporal forms of punishment whereas Daivik dand is seen/temporal punishment. Daivik dand can be financial difficulties, court cases, disrespect, depression, loneliness, oppression, war, starvation, natural disasters, seperation of loved ones etc. Rishi or Pitri punishments are different to the above class. For example through Pitri dand you may have a bent leg even though you may have honor in the world and much money but you still are stuck with having a bent leg.

Dev dand does not exist as Devas are beneficent Beings and help Humans. What Dev dand refers to is imaginary gods that people started praying to and through force of habit created an independent thoughtform. The Brahmins started this trick of praying and worshiping imaginary gods, they made people do convoluted poojas to make money from them and when they did not do the pooja in a correct way the brahmins said that such a person would get dev dand.

Dhan Guru Nanak Ji

​Dhanvaad Khalsa jee.

Dhan Guru Nanak.......tu heen Nirankaar

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 7 years later...
  • 4 months later...
5 hours ago, Laal Singh said:

As years go by, it is becoming evident that there is no paap, punn, good deed, bad deed. All in One, One in All. Everybody is God, God is everybody. A beautiful tamasha going on.

Agree most of what you say, but Why does Gurbani talk of Punn and Paap then Veer Ji? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
  • 2 months later...
On 7/29/2023 at 4:21 AM, Premi said:

Agree most of what you say, but Why does Gurbani talk of Punn and Paap then Veer Ji? 

Everything happens as per His plan.

Within this grand plan, on a temporal level, we get advice from the Guru about right and wrong to help us make decisions.

But does this mean that people who don't know any better are going against His plan?

NO, not in the overall scheme of things, but YES, according to temporal religious and spiritual rules.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...