Jump to content

Why didnt Guru Nanak ji remained his own successor?


Recommended Posts

Satsriakal veerji!
One thought came in my mind late a night thinking of our gurus.

1)Why did Guru Nanak ji didn't remained his own successor like Gautam Buddha of Buddhists and Mahavir of Jains?

2) Why Guru Gobind Singh ji told us Guru Maneo Granth but not human Guru just like  Guru nanak dev ji said?

3)Guru Nanak dev ji loved his best friend Bhai Maradana ji (Muslim) who was a Muslim

4) Guru Gobind Singh Ji told us not to trust Muslim in 52 Hukams ?

Why contractdictions between our 1sr Guru Guru Nanak ji and  our 10th Guru Gobind Singh ji

5) Guru Nanak ji lived like a Sadhu in old sikh arts paints?

6) Guru Gobind Singh ji lived a king in old sikh art paints ?

Please answer this. I am just writing this to become a better sikh and gain better knowledge about sikhi.

Bhul Chukk Maff veerji if I seemed rude somewhere.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Parunoid said:

Why did Guru Nanak ji didn't remained his own successor like Gautam Buddha of Buddhists and Mahavir of Jains?

Guru Sahib did. The Gurus are 1 jot with 12 forms

1 hour ago, Parunoid said:

Why Guru Gobind Singh ji told us Guru Maneo Granth but not human Guru just like  Guru nanak dev ji said?

ਬਾਣੀ ਗੁਰੂ ਗੁਰੂ ਹੈ ਬਾਣੀ ਵਿਚਿ ਬਾਣੀ ਅੰਮ੍ਰਿਤੁ ਸਾਰੇ ॥
The Word, the Bani is Guru, and Guru is the Bani. Within the Bani, the Ambrosial Nectar is contained.

1 hour ago, Parunoid said:

Why contractdictions between our 1sr Guru Guru Nanak ji and  our 10th Guru Gobind Singh ji

Where does it say that in 52 hukams. Guru Sahib had no hate

1 hour ago, Parunoid said:

5) Guru Nanak ji lived like a Sadhu in old sikh arts paints?

6) Guru Gobind Singh ji lived a king in old sikh art paints ?

Miri Piri. Focus less on outside qualities, more on inside qualities

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Parunoid said:

Satsriakal veerji!
One thought came in my mind late a night thinking of our gurus.

1)Why did Guru Nanak ji didn't remained his own successor like Gautam Buddha of Buddhists and Mahavir of Jains?

2) Why Guru Gobind Singh ji told us Guru Maneo Granth but not human Guru just like  Guru nanak dev ji said?

3)Guru Nanak dev ji loved his best friend Bhai Maradana ji (Muslim) who was a Muslim

4) Guru Gobind Singh Ji told us not to trust Muslim in 52 Hukams ?

Why contractdictions between our 1sr Guru Guru Nanak ji and  our 10th Guru Gobind Singh ji

5) Guru Nanak ji lived like a Sadhu in old sikh arts paints?

6) Guru Gobind Singh ji lived a king in old sikh art paints ?

Please answer this. I am just writing this to become a better sikh and gain better knowledge about sikhi.

Bhul Chukk Maff veerji if I seemed rude somewhere.

SSA Parunoid Jee,

Following are the answers to your questions as per my view in the same order of them:

1)  Each Saint, Gurmukh, Guru Sahiban, act as per the hukum of Waheguru, we are nobody to question them if only we believe and trust in them.

2)  It is just a matter of undrstanding and interpreting those words, some take it literally, some base their belief on the general teachings, revelations,  pointers, throughout the Bani.

 After all, each and everyone acts according to their budhi and past karam. 

3) Mardana was muslim outwardLy, but within Him was the Jot of Akal Purukh also, and it was this Jot which Satguru Sachay Patshah saw fit to apoint Him as His sucessor.

4) Because, the muslims to which 10th  Patsahee mentions, are ordinary ignorants, spiritually blind, who only want to suck others blood with their hatred and wickedness, so just to  keep us alert and remain aware.

5) He was a sadhu in the sense that He was the embodiment of sadhkee at its full, which means simplicity, humility, love, mercy and truthfullness, the foremost virtues of a true sadhu, but the fact is He lived   a  householder´s life. 

6) Brother, it is not that important if Guru Sahiban, lives like a King or a Sadhu, for that also as said earlier, it is all by His Hukum  which they follow it implicitly.

    Why should that bother  us?   Do we not anyhow usually call them Sachay Patshah?

    Let us not get confused by their outer aspect or appearance, for their true essence is that they are the Supreme Being, Supreme Truth, Waheguru Akal Purukh.

    Look at their teachings, that is most important  which try to remove the heavy chains of agyanta, of moorakhta that we proudly carry upon ourselves as jewels and ornaments, by  attaching ourselves only  to the Lotus Feet of the Lord, by meditating upon Him through His Saacha Nao.

 

* Lastly, if you want to be a better sikh, than follow Guru Jee alone, do not look here and there what others say or do, because that is their limitation. Each one will tell you what to do as per their level of spiritual maturity, awareness or purity, but on the other side, if you follow Guru Jee, than that is the absolute Truth , a perfect  flawless wisdom.

   Remember, when you shall leave this world, Guru Jee the teacher, will be standing to check you, and He will see what you have written on you exam papers. Whether you wrote down  what you saw and heard others doing howsoever intelectual they seemed to be, or whether you wrote down the lessons taught by Him.

  If we write what He has taught us through Gurbani, then He will for sure pass us in the examination called life, otherwise we will remain as failures, and maybe thrown out of the class or school .... for only god knows, when again shall we get admission in that school (human life).

  What a pity, having Guru Jee with us, we shamelessy do not pay attention to their teachings, but rather to the distorted and imperfect understanting of others.

  A monitor in class( howsoever suppossed advanced student) can never ever take the palce of a Teacher. 

  So study the lessons and do the homework taught by the Teacher only, for it is this practice as per Gurbani, which will take us across.

  MAT KOEE BHARAM BHOOLAY SANSAAR  BIN SATGUR KOEE NA UTRAAS PAAR.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 4/2/2021 at 12:24 AM, Parunoid said:

Satsriakal veerji!
One thought came in my mind late a night thinking of our gurus.

1)Why did Guru Nanak ji didn't remained his own successor like Gautam Buddha of Buddhists and Mahavir of Jains?

The ten gurus in human bodies are all forms of guru nanak and sent by waheguru. Their job was to create sikhi and to fully establish all princaples and implemwnt miri piri sant sipahi khalsa etc. And spread sikhi took time of 10 gurus.

 

Quote

2) Why Guru Gobind Singh ji told us Guru Maneo Granth but not human Guru just like  Guru nanak dev ji said?

After 10 gurus sikh religion was finished and ready and the real guru (shabad guru /gian) was moved into sri guru granth sahib. We do not worship body of yuru nanak we value his gian and knowledge in his gurbani.

Quote

3)Guru Nanak dev ji loved his best friend Bhai Maradana ji (Muslim) who was a Muslim

There is bani of 15 bhagats (including hindus and muslims) in sri guru granth sahib, there is bani of 11 bhatts ij sri guru granthsahib. These people became maha purakhs and one with waheguru so there bani was truth like waheguru.

Quote

4) Guru Gobind Singh Ji told us not to trust Muslim in 52 Hukams ?

These are derived from not so reliable sources.

Edit: mentioning answer for above point, dasma patshah compiled sri guru granth sahib if he thought not to trust muslims why would he keep their bani in gurbani. These are all lies spread by brahminvaadi forces to pollute sikhi and incorporate it into hinduism.

Quote

Why contractdictions between our 1sr Guru Guru Nanak ji and  our 10th Guru Gobind Singh ji

5) Guru Nanak ji lived like a Sadhu in old sikh arts paints?

These are not reliable, guru ji did not live like he actually was dully against and said you can only achieve mukti and become one with waheguru if you live house life not hide in mountains.

Also could be because guru ji was travellor and unlike dasma patsha did not lead army etc.

Quote

6) Guru Gobind Singh ji lived a king in old sikh art paints ?

Answered slightly above 

Remeber these are not real pictures so should not be used to make assumptions.

Quote

Please answer this. I am just writing this to become a better sikh and gain better knowledge about sikhi.

Bhul Chukk Maff veerji if I seemed rude somewhere.

Bhul chuk maf

Wjkk wjkf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...