shastarSingh

Had a talk with Sant Hari Singh randhawe wale. He said that there is lots of difference between Gobind Gita and krishan's gita and Sant ji will make a video in the future explaining the differences between the two. Sant ji's number is +919855103132

https://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/85870-mention-of-gobind-gita-in-sarbloh-granth/

Darshan Singh kashi ji who got Gobind Gita published told me that the language of Gobind Gita is very easy and simple language.

https://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/89306-proof-that-gobind-gita-is-an-adaption/

How do u explain this? Krishan drowned in the world ocean.

I like bhagti movement. Don't like advait. It doesn't believe that soul meets Vaheguru. In fact, soul was never created. It was always brahm. Advait is full of complex thoughts and many of those complex thoughts are false. Some Sikhs feel that if they master these complex thoughts, they will become big gyani. It's all ego and Haume game.

Advait is full of mistakes. Gurmat is different from advait. https://gurmatbibek.com/forum/read.php?3,24967 Advaita VedantaAdvaita was popularized by Shankracharya and this philosophy gives a very strange twist to the equation:1 + 1 = 1But in reality, the equation should be read as 0 + 1 = 1 or perhaps as 1 + 0 = 1.They believe that there is no difference between the Jeev and Brahm. In fact, they believe that Jeev in actuality is Brahm but due to Avidya (ignorance), it considers itself to be not Brahm. In dark, a rope seems like snake and the fear and reaction of the Jeev is real, even though the object of fear – snake – never existed. They consider the world too, to be unreal and totally non-existent. They believe that due to ignorance, the world seems to be but is not. When Avidya ceases to exist or is cleared with Gyaan (jnana), the Jeev realizes that it is Brahm itself. And all this while, when the world experience was going on, the Nirguna Brahm, was totally unaware of the creation and Avidya. The Nirguna Brahm was not even aware of the world creation, then how can He be of any help?So the equation is very strange for this philosophy:0 + 1 = 1, where 0 represents Brahm, because according to them, Jeev is the Brahm. Or you can say that there is only Brahm and there never was the Jeeva, the world, Jada or anything else. There is only one Brahm, and nothing else exists. The world never existed.This philosophy was more in response to the Buddhist philosophy that had overtaken whole of Indian subcontinent. It is sad and disheartening that many modern sants subscribe to this almost Atheist like philosophy. Frankly, if Brahm is totally Nirgun in the sense that it is totally aloof from the world, then it is also true that Brahm cannot hear our pleas, Ardaas and can't help us salvation. The salvation then totally depends on the effort of the Jeev. Furthermore, there can be no real concept of Prema-Bhagti because Prema Bhagti can be done if there is a real Deity as opposed to a indifferent, unaware Nirguna Brahm.I can't help pointing out that, if all the illusion of this world and Jeev had been caused by Avidya, then where did Avidya come from, when originally there was only one Brahm and this Brahm did not create the world, the Jeev and never intended to create it either? Some Advaitins respond by saying that Avidya is Anaadee (eternal, i.e. is without a beginning), then they hurt their principle of Advaita Brahm i.e. non-dual Brahm because then Brahm is no longer alone; Avidya too is as eternal and existent as Brahm. Furthermore they make Avidya a real substance, which it is not. If they say that Avidya was caused due to ignorance of Brahm, then too they firstly they make Brahm no longer non-dual or unattributable and secondly, they inadvertently make Brahm responsible for creation of ignorance. Either way, the Advaitins cannot win with their philosophy of Avidya. Why do some of our Sikhs Sants and scholars believe in such a flawed philosophy?

Guru Sahib is the greatest. Instead of feeling proud to be a sikh of Guru Sahibaan, we Sikhs are trying to please the world by saying that all avtars are equal.

Only Gurmat is 100% correct. Advait is full of mistakes. Gurbani pankitis are very simple to understand. Let's not make them complex by bringing in advait.

Guru Granth Sahib ji also says that God created countless krishnas and ramas. https://gurmatbibek.com/forum/read.php?3,1398

https://gurmatbibek.com/forum/read.php?3,4772

https://www.sikhsangat.com/index.php?/topic/45625-krishan-is-called-an-insect-in-sri-dasam-granth/

From personal experience, I don't feel violent the day I eat meat Violence stems from krodh and krodh is kept in check by reading Gurbani.

It's a belief of Nihangs that when an animal is done jhatka while reading Bani, the animal gets human birth in gursikh house and is liberated.

@dalsingh101

Video unavailable at my place. What's the video about ?

Bhai Jivan Singh ji' brother got shaheed in Chamkaur war. Bhai Jivan Singh's father in law and 2 elder sons got shaheed in Chamkaur war. Bhai Jivan Singh's mother and 2 younger sons got shaheed near Sirsa river. Bhai Jivan Singh's father got shaheed in chandni chowk in Delhi.

The photo states there are 4 persons of the name Sangat Singh. Younger brother of Bhai Jiwan Singh (bhai jaita ji) was also of the name Sangat Singh. He also got shaheed in Chamkaur war. So there are 5 Sangat Singhs.

The photo is taken from the book 'Guru ke bete' by Jaswant Singh. His contact no. is +919814575196. Book can be bought at https://csjs.com/shop/guru-ke-bete-2/ https://www.sikhvirasat.ca/books/guru-ke-bete-book-by-jaswant-singh-sikhvirasat

Ant akelaa garr mein.... Is also from Das Gur Katha.