harkeeratsingh

10 minutes ago, GurjantGnostic said:

Some additional points you made to set the ground. 

Hp1. You said the Hindu Devte are the avtar of Akal and perfect manifestations.

Mp1. You said the Gurbani confirms Muhammad as the last true of the abrahamic prophets. 

Tp1. You claim therefore the Quran is true and that the Bible is false. And that Bible is not Keetab in Gurbani. 

Cp1. You claim that Bhai Naand Laal Ji is approved Vaaran and in line with the rest of Gurbani. 

Bp1. You claim that Guru Nanak Dev Ji was not Waheguru when he, as you out it, was shitting his nappies. 

Bp2. You call the Guru Sabhain God directly, not just mnaifestations of his Sanjog. For which Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj condemns you Dukh. 

I will teach you etiquettes; What's shared elsewhere should stay there. And a disclaimer for the benefit of those reading, false false, false, false.

@GurjantGnostic

Before you can say anything it's finished. Now you can without me carry on speaking.

However, my opinion is Guru doesn't affirm or negate Kateb, bible, Jesus or Christ. What is mentioned to Muslims, who made up 50% of India at that time, is, don't say Kateb is wrong if you haven't read it.

On a side note, Kateb is translated as bible but I hold the opinion that the bible is corrupt, not a reliable source of information, not the Kateb which was given to Jesus, not the Kateb Guru is talking about, and the spiritual authority in the christian tradition themselves accept the bible is corrupt.

Anyways, Jesus is not mentioned in Bani, I think because he's not relevant, he's not important - we come from a tradition where the Guru honors Prophets from different backgrounds by putting their writing in Bani, from low class, poor families, to wealthy ones; there have been countless like Jesus and will be.

Lastly, Guru says a Satgur is someone who knows the Divine, Sat Purkh Jin Janiya, Satgur Tis Ka Nao, so when they say Jesus was Satgur from eternity, I just don't buy that he knew God when he was a baby sh*ttin' in his nappy. 

Thanks for reading. Apologies for my mistakes Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh _/\_