Jump to content

Matheen

Members
  • Posts

    1,589
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    4

Posts posted by Matheen

  1. It all depends on what they think the 'Dao' is. If it is 'nothingness' then they have no chance, because they have no knowledge of the atma. It is the longing of the atma to return to where it came from that we get tuned into and this leads to bairaag and prem.

    Gurbani tells us in quite a few places that any form of bhagti done without prem will not get you anywhere.

  2. it has been died out in india but people who are from east africa and singerpore keep the same style alive.

    Not really. The 'Kenyan' style only became popular in Kenya a few generations ago. If you look at very old photos of the Sangat there, they wore normal Indian styles - in many cases more rustic than you find in Indian cities, more similar to styles in the pinds. There was a shift between people who are now in their nineties and the generation that came after.

  3. Who do you want to speak out? How many people would have watched Zee Tv to get this alleged story? Think about it, would they send a letter to the CID outlining their plans?

    This is no different to coutless other allegations and false cases by the Indian Police. It's all a load of bs and I don't see what you're getting worked up about. Babbar Khalsa doesn't even exist in its original form.

  4. If you had read the Tankhahnama you wouldn't make such a (foolish) statement. Tankhahnama doesn't mention Jaap. It only says to recite Japji, Rehraas and Kirtan Sohila (in verses 25/26).

    and I quote, "Waheguru Pun Mantreh Jaap. Kar Ishnan Parhe Jap Jaap (2)" - Rehatnama and Tankahnama of Bhai Nand Lal Ji. :rolleyes:

    You can tell what type of ink is used by looking at a photo? If you had gone to India, stayed with real Singhs and seen those birs yourself, I would believe you. As it stands, all your 'knowledge' is from the internet and your level/ manner of debating is that found in the comments section of Youtube videos.

    None of your 'proofs' are valid. Try again.

  5. Karishna existed somewhere in time line and can't be a true name. Same can be said for other Sargun names.

    Please comment.

    Gurbani itself makes that clear, especially Dasam Bani.

    Satnam just means that His name is true. True because it is permanent, never changing, and always was, always will be. Something that changes or dies to be born again can not be considered 'sat'. Waheguru has infinite names, but for us, the most important one is Gurmantar. You can't pick and choose which naam to jaap or keep changing it - there's no way you'll be able to concentrate.

    Gurmantar is indeed Waheguru, but it only becomes a Gurmantar when given to you by your Guru - i.e. during Amrit Sanchar.

  6. Dating is done easily. Inder Singh (lakhwinder singh of usa aka singh2 on this site) and Lamba have claimed that there is a 1698 Dasam Granth Bir, its Tatkara pic is on Patshahi10.org. It is fake, how do we know? I got pic of same bir where Zafarnama is written in same ink and handwriting,......

    Got a link to the photos? Have you seen the bir yourself?

    Where in Guru Sahib does it say to wake up and read JapJi Sahib and Anand Sahib?

  7. Guptsingh, how do you know who compiled the old birs we have - do you expect to find signatures of the compiler?

    I mentioned in another thread how no bir, whether Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji or Sri Dasam Granth, has been accurately dated. The reason is that accurate dating methods are all destructive. Many of the banis within Sri Dasam Granth have dates written in them, by Guru Sahib. For Sikhs who have faith in Guru Ji, that is enough proof.

    Can you explain to me which teachings of Sri Guru Granth Sahib Ji you follow and which ones from Sri Dasam Granth you don't?

  8. What debate are you going on about? why don't you come here? Why did you cancel the debate after making flyers on facebook?

    Like Guru Sahib says, sometimes the only way you can get a moorakh to understand something is by using a danda. Here we have someone who hasn't even taken Amrit, doesn't follow many of Guru Ji's hukams and he thinks he understands Dasam Bani enough to curse it. Sharam kar!

×
×
  • Create New...