Homer Simpson

If not ALL Muslims say that then surely it cannot be within the scriptures as if it was, why would they reject it?! And you havent tolf me to f off?! This is a forum remember, its the rules of this forum to ask questions??!!

Refer to the new topic then!

I would like to ask Javanmard: You claim Imam Ali gave Amrit to Satguru Nanak Maharaj...Then why is it stated in the Nanak Prakash (I think it is) that Maharaj saw Vishnu? You paint this picture that Muslims see Sikhi as another path to attaining God and that the Guru's are Pirs of God. NO Muslim claims or says what you are! Where are you getting your knowledge from?! If what you say is true..Then why do they say Maharaj is NOT the Light of God, Sikhi is NOT a path to God??!!

I would like to ask Javanmard: You claim Imam Ali gave Amrit to Satguru Nanak Maharaj...Then why is it stated in the Nanak Prakash (I think it is) that Maharaj saw Vishnu? You paint this picture that Muslims see Sikhi as another path to attaining God and that the Guru's are Pirs of God. NO Muslim claims or says what you are! Where are you getting your knowledge from?! If what you say is true..Then why do they say Maharaj is NOT the Light of God, Sikhi is NOT a path to God??!!

Who's upset? Im asking you 'just a simple question' also!

What has it got to do with you anyway? Who are you that people should offer explanations to you?!!!

Shaheediyan admin cut: no personal attacks please, this is your first verbal warning.

And Russian dancing...hey drawrof??

yes! I was expecting the famous Javanmard diversion of everything to Islam...no need to use the names of Guru Har Rai Ji as a means to validate your claims!

You shouldnt mock 'Hindu' logic...its obviuolsy not as simple as you put it, with your example of a knife. There are far more links regarding this topic than the mere pronounciation of a name and or term!

Islamic tradtions have been influenced by Indian traditons, never the less...whats more is that the Jewish mystical traditon of the Kabala actually took ideas from India..

Whos Tej? And also it doesnt deny the links are there also does it?

That doesnt proove anything.

There was a large influence of Indian elements which found its way into the Islamic traditions, did it not?

http://iworld.proweblog.com/blog/archives/2005/08/26/145/ http://www.viewzone.com/abraham.html Very interesting, rather pleasing to the Indian mind, one might say!