GuptSingh1699

I am not aware of it, nor is something written 2 years back more important than things written in 1700s. Now say; Is Bachittar Natak right or Guru Granth Sahib Ji? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Well read in Sikh history? You don't know me so don't pass personal comments on me. Bhatt Vahis, give me exact quotes of them. And name me which Rehatnamas you are talking of. Get me that article. By whom is it? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Haha... Don't you have acces to a doctor??????? He may have acces to different IP's, but in Canada. I'm right here sitting in Europe. This topic is about Dasam Granth and not Naam. So Inder, you choose Guru Granth Sahib on Guru Amar Das being Bhalla or DG saying Guru Amar Das being a Bedi? Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

I am not duplicate Khalsa Fauj. Ask mods to do IP check. I do not follow Charitars nor do I keep Dasam Granth writer(s) in high regard (means I don't impersonate like them). Seems like you got a few screws lose on the upper section of your body. guptsingh84 is not equal to GuptSingh1994. There are many people on other forums with Singh variant, should I say that they are your ID's ? Don't pull chariters on me. You do not make sense. Do all PRO DG guys have same maryada? AKJ is pro DG and so is DDT, but one doesn't believe in Raagmala while the other does. I believe in Naam Simran and also do it, I don't care about Harmanjit Singh nor Inder Singh Ghagga's stance on Naam Simran. Howhever I stand united with them on DG issue, just like all your maryada differing Sampardas like Nihang, AKJ and DDT unite on DG issue. Waheguru has gifted you all with brains... They are there to be used, not for filling empty stuff in the head. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh

Inder, don't create a scene yo. I'm 200% anti DG and I love to do Waheguru Simran. I wake up early in morning as instructed by Guru Raam Daas in his bani 'Gur Satgur Ka Jo Sikh Akhaye, So Bhalke Uth Har Naam Dhiavey". As I said before I love to recite Waheguru. I believe in reincarnation, since it IS a part of Nankian philosophy. I bow to Shabad Guru, yes. It is in no way a form of idol worship. SGGS Maharaj should be kept in Prakash, whoever keeps it in cupboards is a maha moorakh. Stop spreading lies on sites like SikhSangat. Your one big liar. Since you guys love to say Mahakaal is the destroyer of Kaal, would you also say that Maha Moorakh is the destroyer of Moorakhs? Mahakaal has 4 arms, loves booze and green stuff. Bhai Kahan Singh Nabha in his Gurmat Martand says that it is necessary for a Sikh of Mahakaal to do Nashapatta... You do that? Your emotional blackmail and rants won't have any effect on me, do straight debate. Amrit Sanchaar Banis are decided by the Guru Panth. We can not change that. Just like these 5 were finalised in the 1920s-1930s, it could be changed by Panth any time in future. Read Puratan Granths and try to find what Banis were read instead of asking us. My first point against Dasam Granth: 1. * Bachittar Natak says Guru Nanak Dev, Guru Angad Dev and Guru Amar Das were Bedis. (page 128) * SGGS on Ang 1396 and 1401 (Bhatt Bani) clearly say that Guru Amar Das was Bhalla. * Historically Guru Angad Dev was a Trehan and Guru Amar Das (as stated in Gurbani) a Bhalla. Big time contradiction. Who is right? Bachittar Natak or SGGS? Pick one please. You can't pick both as they are contradictory. Pick one. If you pick SGGS then discard DG, if you pick DG then you disown Guru Granth Sahib Ji... In that case I'll ask you to form your own "Kub Shyam Panthis" religion. Waheguru Ji Ka Khalsa Waheguru Ji Ki Fateh