kdsingh80

Question to all scholar of SA , Is this propaganda or truth?

Is their any evidence , one of Bhagat singh's letter where he mentioned he reverted back to Sikhism. I am not trusting marxists but just Bhagat singh's letters .His family could also be the one who knows real truth about him , why will they lie

If I am not wrong Amritdhari sikhs are not allowed to associate with patit's( means the one who took amrit and later willfully broke their Rehat)

http://www.tapoban.org/webforum/read.php?1,3652 Read the above there are contradictions in that https://www.marxists.org/archive/bhagat-singh/1930/10/05.htm And the above is letter from Bhagat singh , he clearly call himself Atheist ,

But sikh society is quite harsh on people who leave their religion or even cut their hair, this is fact which we cannot deny, so people do have different set of rules for high achievers and ordinary, this is reality of life

That is just a story there is no evidence of that

Her political stature is not so large outside USA that people know her , but I was talking about sikh society in general .The other example is Bhagat Singh who despite being Atheist communist is accepted by sikhs as their own great freedom fighter.Sikhs are generally harsh on people who renounce their religion but the who do some big or great acheivement then despite renouncing our people accept those as their own

Nikki Haley is Governer of South Carolina https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikki_Haley She has embraced christianity yet sikh sites still publish articles about her and lot of sikhs are still her fans because she was born in Sikh family and please don't tell me this is the way Sikhs treat ordinary ex sikhs

Because in real world all these things exists and every person know what his/her status is, the minute that person start speaking above that then the society just bash him /her for that. Take the example of Nikki Haley , she abandoned Sikhism and embraced christianity , yet sikh sites publish her articles , not only that there are many apologetic supporters of her .while any other sikh man or woman who cut his hair or abandon Sikhism is always abused by the other sikhs, why this discrimination ? because Nikki Haley has acheived the status which is distant for any Sikh man or woman , so lets forget whether she is Sikh or not , just boot lick her On the other hand how dare an average sikh man or woman leave religion ? he must be punished for that And BTW the military is Kshatriya

Jatts are dominant caste in sikhism , not lower , oppressed

Same old discrimination B.S with no knowledge. Mostly men are doing dirty jobs so women must be discriminated in that too , Majority of workplace deaths are of men so women are discriminated in that too Men must be dreaming about becoming garbage collector , sewer cleaner and dieing at death that's why they stop women from doing these? Coming to becoming Raagi's and kathavachak , sorry t to say but you have hardly any knowledge about it. Most family will be pissed of if their son say that He want's to become Gyani, Kathavachak or Raagi. Most of them want their son to do some white collar job and earn 6 figure salary or go USA canada and send $$.Gyani Kathavachak , Raagi are some jobs in which Punjabi familes are least interested , this is harsh reality of Sikhism. Western gender similarity means when a society see's everything from the eye's of gender and divide equally between two 50:50 everything, though menial jobs' workplace deaths don't count in that. Also if you ask caste of Gyani's , kathavachak , raagi's then you may found that majority of them are from upper caste , so then again blame will be why lower caste is not represented in that, must be discrimination

Plenty of urban khatri , Arora Turbanned sikhs don't see Sikhs and Hindu's as different communnitties while plenty of clean shaven Jatt sikhs will never accept that that Sikhs and Hindu's are same

Is their anybody stopping women from becoming raagi's , katha vachak , members of committee? More men simply does not mean discrimination , it could be the result of interest of men more in these things rather than discrimination. The type of western gender similarity which many are searching in sikhism is hardly going to be found in sikh history

Admin cut is to remind people admin is everywhere on forum just like God in real world.worship him on forum Admin ji admin ji admin ji

Pakistan controlled Kashmir hardly have any sikhs

Voting should be abolished by common folks only those who are associated with gurdwara should be allowed to choose the leaders.There is no way a person who has no knowledge what is going on in gurdwara should be allowed to vpte

This is what many feared and this will break the political back of sikhism

May be few but others are looking sikhs , some are wearing Patka with big joora. Also if they are not sikhs then Kashmiri sikhs should issue clarification that this type of protest never happened

Agenda or no agenda damage is done , If you chant Pakistan zindabad , Afzal guru zindabad and your video is all over net then don't blame anyone if they think that sikhs are muslim sympathisers or even muslims. Also it is same kashimiri's who chanted " Kashmir mein rahana hai to Allah hu kahana hai" .

There is something seriously wrong with sikhs, everywhere they want to fight battle of other people and as a result they got kicked from both sides.

All religions lie about history, there is hardly anything new in it.Hinduism that is practiced today is far from what it really was

Most of Pakistani will believe that Axis of evil USA, India and Israel are behind it so nothing will stop

You are reading too much scientific fiction , these things are at development stage and nobody knows whether they will be available to common people or not, what will be their outcome ? The life of that child if produced should have been closely monitored as he may develop some unanatural illnesses. Btw scientists are also claiming they will create humans without sperm and egg http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-1223617/No-men-OR-women-needed-artificial-sperm-eggs-created-time.html Also the cost factor will also come in . assuming that two women require 100 million dollar to produce baby then how many women will opt for that? Science is claiming all type of weird shit. nobody knows the future

When you join a religious forum then get ready to be abused. Such is the standard of religious forum.people claim religion makes you calm , humble but online forums tell you different story , I joined and discussed several things on other forum but hardly get abused but here for no reason You are abused

I heard the name of Pandit Nischal Singh https://www.thesikhencyclopedia.com/biographies/sikh-mystics-and-traditional-scholars/nishchal-singh-pandit-sant As I said this is word of mouth and it was long time back, I will need to ask some elder in my family regarding this