anyone who can solve the confusion????????? JI AYIAAN NU

[arti_kaur]

"DUKH BHANJNI SAHIB" PAATH IS FOR GETTING RID OF ALL DUKHS

AND

"SUKHMANI SAHIB" IS FOR HAVING ALL SUKHS

SO SHOULD WE DO BOTH PAATH EVERYDAY!!!!!!

OR ONE OF THEM WILL DO

AS I KNOW THAT ONE PAATH OF "SUKHMANI SAHIB" IS NECESSARY ONCE IN A DAY

TACKLE IT PLEASE!!!!!!

[Guest]

Bani should not be used as a mean, just to make our earthly lives better. The purpose of gurbani is to meet waheguru ji.

So Sukh Dukh are temporary and will not last, thats why u shud do path for mukti rather than worldy pleasures.

[tSingh]

Not quite;

dukh bhanjani sahib and sukhmani sahib are means of crossing the bhaav saagar. They produce no worldly pleasures. The absence of dukh through gurbani will potentially lead to santokh. Santokh in essence will produce dheeraj (stoic patience). In otherwords, wordly events have emotional consequences on the imperfected mun. Dukh bhanjani is a means of overcoming this and bringing about aatmic development.

Sukhmani on the otherhand produces different adhyatmic virtues. Sukh here is not the worldy pleasure but 'anand' or bliss since waheguru is satchitanand swaroop.

Therefore it is a mistake to assume such banis can be used to produce worldy pleasure or further maya. Equally the underlying desires of those who read these banis are not for worldy pleasure but spiritual development (whether knowingy or not).

hope this helps

[arti_kaur]

thanx tsingh ji and amardeep singh ji very well said but i know that

"SUKH DUKH IS MANN KI BIRTHA TUJ HI AAGE SAARE"

well thanks but u know that there is an importance of each and every paath in life and that importance vi want to know actually

[arti_kaur]

very well said tsingh ji u r right veerji

thanks for taking out ur time to give me such a valuable answer ji i really appriciate ur concern ji

once again thanks

vjkk vjkf

[tableji]

i kno that wen eva im upset n i read any gurbani i feel better afterwards. bt i try to read salok mhl 9, or sukhman sahib, really help!!