John

Javanmard, what is this clear defintion of Kufr?

Anyhow, you informed this forum that the defintion of Kafr is quite clear, so what is this clear definition?

The moderators of this site are a bunch of cry babies, everything which does not comply with their view must be locked, or put into another section. Guru Nanak Maharaaj went to Mecca, accpet it!!

Javanmard, what is this clear defintion of Kufr?

Javanmard, what will you say to Amardeeps comments 'i dont think they will respect him anymore. my shia friends have much respect for the Gurus as ordinary men because of the way they lived and their love for God, but when it comes to the statement of creation a new religion, then they lose that respect because these men are to be killed in an islamic state. ' This is far from the picture that you paint, that Shias love the Gurus!!

Javanmard, what is this clear defintion of Kufr?

Kam1825, It's still is a pitty that the Sikh community cannot answer simple things, this is obviously due to too much five knuckle shuffling and not enough reading.... Niranjana, there are plently of Muslims which accept Satguru Nanak Dev Ji Maharaaj as one of their Pirs, as a Wallhiallah, this is different from a status of that of a Prophet.

Some will say that it is written in the Holy Quran, so therefore they have every right to tell you.....as it is the Word of Allah......... For people that pride themselves in being Sikhs of the Satguru, its a shame that no one on this forum can answer these simple questions!!

Kam1825 that recording is terribly hard to listen to and understand, why dont you just explain what it is that the Katha says please

Please explain your answer Guv

I am sure that there are different ways of explaining what various terms from the Quran actaully mean

Niranjana, thank you for your input, ATLEAST YOU WERE BOTHERED. I would ask a number of questions to the person who put fourth that claim to you: 1. Where this person states 'as a Sikh you are being misled, I would ask; misled from what? 2. Islam is the notion of and means as well as requires Submission to Allah, so Islam or Submission of oneself to Allah Almighty IS the only way to attain Allah? 3. Find me a quote from ANY of the Great Satgurus which ISNT about Islam-Submission to Allah

Its soo heart warming to know that people on this forum are interested in other philosophies....how very open minded.....stop five knuckle shuffling and get replying!!

Come on get your fingers out!!!!

Thats it ignore this thread you ignorant admin cut.

Javanmard Guv is correct, please explain your statement

As you will be aware, there are some groups or individuals which pride themselves on the notion that we are all going against Allah as we do not follow the Holy Qur'an as it is the Word of Allah.. What would the people on this forum input regarding this???

What is Batin within Islamic thinking?

Maybe your complaining about the rapper getting it on with girls because you cant get any action!!! Simrun255

FORGET THE MEMBERS THEY HAVE A PHOBIA OF ISLAM...ITS EVIDENT, YOU ARE THE MODERATOR, USE YOUR JUDGEMENT AND CONSIDER OPENING THE THREAD

OH AND DONT BOTHER EDITING MY POST...CRY BABIES!!!

I REQUEST THE SIKH SHIA DISCUSSION TO RE-OPEN. N30 YOU OBVIOULSY HAVE TAKEN ACTION ON BEHALF OF THE ISLAMOPHOBS WHAT ABOUT THOSE THAT APPRECIATED THE DISCUSSION!!!!

I find it absolutely appauling that people on this forum are such narrow minded bafoons..... the Shia Sikh discussion was a good discussion. ITS A PITY THAT NARROW MINDED ISLAMOPHOBICS CANNOT APPRECIATE MORE THAN WHAT THEY HOLD.....which is NOTHING really Ya Nanak Shah!!!!

It was a genuine question Javanmard, when I reffered to us I mean Sikhi Thank you

What does Islam have to do with us, why have an Islamic icon up, Javanmard?