Embrace Islam Or Leave Valley, Sikhs Threatened

[kdsingh80]

If Hindu government is smart they will immediately separate Kashmir Valley from the non-Muslim areas of J&k (Jammu and Ladakh) and just give it to Pakistan, otherwise they will see Jammu and Ladakh also being conquered along with Kashmir Valley.

Giving up even an inch of area will mean disintegration of India.The morale of Indian army,CRPF will go down.many separatists movement will start feeling that if India can accept Defeat in Kashmir Why can't they accept in their area.

In this entire discussion people are forgetting one thing that Indian muslim population along with illegal migration from bangladesh the muslim population is increasing day by day and they are getting politically stronger too.So who knows what will happen in next 20-30 years

[kdsingh80]

duplicate

Edited August 21, 2010 by kdsingh80

[kdsingh80]

I'm thinking also, when America does leave Afghanistan, I would bet there will be a mobilisation of Jihadis in the Kashmir area soon after (presuming Kashmir hasn't gone by then that it). That is not to say that Kashmiris themselves do not want independence but rather that these other forces are likely to come into play in future, once they arefreed from fighting the yanks.

Can India handle this?

I doubt it.

India already handled Kashmir along with Afghan and other fighers from 89-01

without the help of any country .At that time Indian economy was very weak and even Pak tried to take it by force in kargil war.So there is no reason India cannot handle it in future with much stronger economy and support from west

[chatanga1]

Giving up even an inch of area will mean disintegration of India.The morale of Indian army,CRPF will go down.

GOOD!

many separatists movement will start feeling that if India can accept Defeat in Kashmir Why can't they accept in their area.

EVEN BETTER!

[laalsingh]

Somebody suggested Govt should start allotting 20 acre lots to Punjabi Sikhs. Advertising poster should say, "Buy cheap land in Kashmir. Free AK 47 with land. License to kill invaders."

[Mithar]

Somebody suggested Govt should start allotting 20 acre lots to Punjabi Sikhs. Advertising poster should say, "Buy cheap land in Kashmir. Free AK 47 with land. License to kill invaders."

If that were to happen, so many Sikhs would move to Kashmir that Kashmir problem would be finished within a year!

The former congressi CM of Punjab Kairon was trying his level best in pressuring Nehru to merge the state of J&K with the state of Punjab because he said this would make J&K safe from Pakistani attack because then protecting the state of J&K would become an obligation of the Sikhs of Punjab. Back in CM Kairon's period Haryana and Himachal were not separate, they were still a part of Punjab.

[dalsingh101]

Somebody suggested Govt should start allotting 20 acre lots to Punjabi Sikhs. Advertising poster should say, "Buy cheap land in Kashmir. Free AK 47 with land. License to kill invaders."

Isn't this just a 'oh shite, we can't control the situation anymore, let's maybe get those pugnacious but dimwitted Panjabis involved, now' scenario?

[dalsingh101]

If that were to happen, so many Sikhs would move to Kashmir that Kashmir problem would be finished within a year!

The former congressi CM of Punjab Kairon was trying his level best in pressuring Nehru to merge the state of J&K with the state of Punjab because he said this would make J&K safe from Pakistani attack because then protecting the state of J&K would become an obligation of the Sikhs of Punjab. Back in CM Kairon's period Haryana and Himachal were not separate, they were still a part of Punjab.

When you think about it, Sikhs weren't really trusted by the Congress right from the beginning of India's independence. I wonder what the common perception of Sikhs was pre and post independence?

I get the impression that they weren't liked much in certain quarters.

Edited August 22, 2010 by dalsingh101