angy15

Bulls eye.Very Inspiring!!!
Yes he has that repo amoung young generations.He is a kind of rockstar here in india .His dewaans are like rock concert. The traditional kathavacaks specially the taksali are very dull and boring to listen less of gurbani more of mystical stories.
Let us try to educate and remove misconception abt him to   some of our popular members here.
 

In fact, he inspired me to take the Amrit. He inspired me to come into sikhi. I am very grateful to him for that. I loved raising my hands over my head for the Jaikaras: ‘Boley so Nihaal, Sat Sri Akaal’ at the dnd of each kirtan divan @ our local Gurdwara! I don’t get it, why sikhs hate other sikhs so much. My dad likes him too. He says young people can relate to him much better because he represents their era better than most others that no one even heard of!  Good luck to them for hating him so much, I pray they will soon see their folly!

Here are my top 5 questions for Dhandrianwale: 
 
1. What inspired you to become a preacher?
 
2. What motivates you to stay focussed despite being surrounded by negative people with narrow focus, that refuse to grow in their hearts? 
 
3. How do you manage to stay above all the destructive elements caused by those that lack your vision as well as your imagination, those that rather perish by not allowing the eyes and ears of their hearts to see or hear, on daily basis?
 
4. Obviously you are a great visionary, what are your chances or expectations of fulfilling your vision in terms of spreading Sikhi?
 
5. Have you ever considered moving abroad, writing books or giving talks on Sikhi in schools, colleges or even at universities, both, at home and abroad, something similar to the great and successful Yogi Harbajan Singh?
 

Where is he saying this ? is this recorded anywhere ?
As many , many years ago i went to couple of his diwaans in the UK , he was very good , simple to understand  , motivational  main focus , Attach to the Guru . I didnt judge his personal life  , thats up to him what he does.
My personal view is that there are many people who look like sikh but want sikhi to be abolished , he is not one of them . I think he has a good following and getting bigger , so some start to spread rumours to belittle someone having influence so to stop him/them in their tracks . They feel threatened and want to see their downfall.
 
 

Do you even know the definition of the word "Guru"?

I think I will just leave it.

.

.

Its already happening .He attracts large amount of Followers.But Taksali attracts just handfull only. I myself have been witnessed to it
They cant debate  him on logic,nether on Gurmat .All they can do is cowardly acts like killing ,removing turbans.There Taksals are nothing but extension of Akali Dal exorting money .
 

One thing abt this Taksali Group is that there  version of Sikh Philosophy is standing on 1000-2000 odd sakhis heavily infected  with Vedantic Virus.Thats the reason they are Jittery over Single Rehat Marayda, it will break there foundation.
 

You will not like me after reading this.

If God grant me one wish, I would ask God to not let any humans (Sikhs, non-Sikhs, anyone) to join this forum.

Seriously, because only thing I see and read in this forum is nothing but Brahmanwaad Ver 2.0.

Everyone, except few people like @CdnSikhGirl, are doing nothing but just ripping apart Sikhi.

The Sachi-Suchi Practical, Heuristic, Realistic and Simplistic philosophy of Guru Nanak Ji is nowhere seen here. All Guru ji lived a normal human life doing all functions which a normal human do, but the only thing that differentiates them was their VIRTUES. They had the Gyaan. They had all the VIRTUES such as Charity,compassion, courage, courteousness, diligence, discipline, empathy, endurance, fairness, faith, fidelity, forgiveness, fortitude, generosity, honesty, honor, hopefulness, hospitality, humility, impartiality, innocence, integrity, joy, kindness, mercy, modesty, morality, patience, peacefulness, perseverance, prudence, purity, purposefulness, respectfulness, self-discipline, sincerity, sympathy, temperance, thankfulness, trustworthiness, truth, wisdom etc. which a human of high moral standard should possess.

They lead a normal life but it was a life of SIGNIFICANCE, and they lived a practical life to teach and make us understand. They showed us ways by setting example for us in every aspects of life.

Guru Nanak Ji didn't perform any magic shows to attract people during their udasis (trips). It was the GYAAN, the Reformed and Revolutionized KNOWLEDGE, which people got attracted to. What I see in this forum is only the  ALIF-LAILA version of Sikhi. Behind every action there is some supernatural and mystical things associated to it.

As long as sex is concerned, what Guru ji taught was simple.
Having sex with neighbor's wife makes us a bad Human (or for that matter not even a Human), and on the other side having sex with our own wife and being loyal and faithful makes us a good Human. Simple as that, period.
What I see in this forum is whole mystical thing revolving around whether Guru Ji had sexual intercourse or not. Was our Guru ji aliens? Why would they not have sex with their wives? What's wrong in that? This is how all humans are born. Nobody is ever born in this world without it.

Having children without sex doesn't makes our Guruji great, it's the Loyalty, Trust and Faithfulness that makes them Great.

I was happy initially when I joined this forum but now I would never want anyone to see what's going inside this.

I know, now people will start bashing me.

Ha ha ! don't be sorry yet,  wait and watch, he will be dragging all your mystical sant, brahmgyanis, mahapurkhs, vidya martands etc. in the arena 😄

Similarly, adding great prefixes such as 108, Vidya Martand, Brahmgyani,  Mahapurkh, etc. won't either.

What kind of spiritual vibes are you looking for? Do you really think good people carry some Auras around their head or vibes around them?

If this is the case, why Lehna Ji didn't immediately recognize Guru Nanak in their first meeting? Didn't he receive strong vibes?

Right, I already suggested last year to change this forum's name to Brahmanwaad Ver 2.0. These people have their own version of Sikhi.

See this:
 

You will never find good abt him in this forum.top members of this forum's are taksali influenced and believe that there beliefs is the real teaching .

Yes I Agree with you .But who agree with him you can't call them cultist ,anti Gurmat or abuse them .
This was the point  from  which my discussion started .This was the Very first point I made that "some  of you may disagree with his preaching " but   he attracts large gathering.
Let me again Say the Title is Misleading  it should be  Dhadrianwala Vs Taksali and not Great Sikhs .
 
Satnam
 
 

This is your perception. You are no one to give certificates who is Sikh or Non Sikh .Sangat will decide who is who?
Multiple marayada has created  chaos in Gurudwaras .Every Dera, Taksal ,Baba has his own RM.
Ranjit Singh Dadherwala has spoken abt Ek SRM which is a indeed a great step   to help keep unity and harmony which everyone should acknowledge .

Did you forget his education and upbringing was from same school of thought as yours.Which he was wise enough to get rid off.
Well i may not have a brain but a fool will also think twice abt the tiltes given below.
Vidya martand of the Sikh Panth, Srimaan 108 Sant Gyani Gurbachan Singh jee Khalsa Bhindranwale.
Please tell me who has given these  titles   to this man.

No one can beat you Paapiman.

Seriously, you have your own version of Sikhi. Just like how brahmin use to fulfill his desire by associating things with devis and devtas, similarly you do it with our Gurus.

Don't get offended, that's the reality.

I would not say that it is ultimate knowledge, but you should watch this. 
 

There are couple of quotes from Socrates that I personally like:
Question: What should be discussed?
- Strong minds discuss ideas, Average minds discuss events, Weak minds discuss people.
Question: Where to learn from?
- Smart people learn from everything and everyone, Average people from their experiences, Stupid people already have all the answers.
Question: How to change the bad habits?
- The secret of change is to focus all of your energy, not on fighting the old, but on building the New.

Wow so many replies 
The videos are basically snippets as mentioned before , and his views be they right or wrong it doesnt matter , its like a tennis match , he says something , then the other one , back and forth . 
I'm not a fan of either or defending anyone , but pointing out Sikhi is about  compassion , love , caring .
As mentioned before if he has his own agenda ,anti Sikhi then he will surely pay for it ...... but if the truth needs to be established rather than snippets of videos  they need to confront them face to face . By they I mean people who have Gian and knowledge are on the path themselves. If one refuses , do you stop there ... i dont think so, you have to keep knocking on their door , applying pressure until they do.
If it can be done with tact, with pyar who wouldnt want to listen rather than just getting the boot in from the start.
I'm all for the "truth" and not calling anyone liars . How many here have contacted Ranjit Singh Dhandrianwala about the causes stated in this thread ?
How many here have written to him ?
If this is causing problems in Sikhi , we need to stand up ourselves and educate the sangat , and then post our experiences with the one accused otherwise its just hear say.
I still personally think its progaganda other intelligence forces are playing their part in breaking Sikhi. If a parcharak has been doing good for x many years , joining the sangat then why change all of a sudden , dont make any sense or unless its wahegurus hukam . For arguments sake , if he has dialogue with the sangat/Giani's then I think it needs to be done compassionately so that one realises the truth and makes a U-turn back and  starts doing the good deeds again. Its very easy to break something but very hard to keep intact and its the latter we must focus on.
 

The videos speak for themselves. How are any of the things he is saying good for Sikhi? He says "what is the point of breaking Gods law of nature (sleeping at night) to worship God?
 
People follow HIM, they don't follow what he's saying and seeing if he is right. They are cultists and he has become a cult leader. He could have millions of followers like that arabian cult but it doesn't make it right.

This is a complete joke
The first video not showing the full context just snippets , they can edit anything nowadays and get people to believe anything
Plus this is a good way of knocking someone down who is doing good for Sikhi
We must wake up and judge for ourselves rather than videos like the above. This is all propaganda by some few individuals trying to put him down , as he is waking up the sangat 
Has anyone been to his diwans ?
Ask him directly , if you have concerns i'm sure he will answer them.
We have this problem , cant see someone in the kaum doing well , rumours are spread and be person defamed. Why ???
Why now ???
wHo is behind all of this ??
Have we ever thought about this ?
If he is doing wrong , then he will have to suffer ..., sangat are not that stupid .
Why do you think he has some many followers ?
 
 
 

No one can beat you Pappiman. I have tried and tested. The kind of intellectual knowledge you have, you can write your own granth. Forget 108, you are 100000008.