SAadmin Posted July 30, 2015 Report Posted July 30, 2015 We are thinking in terms of limiting authencity debates on sri dasam granth on this forum as recently we have been seeing lot of forum members energy is put on debates and discussion which is fine but if whole forum members energy is directed towards one specific topic, one specific area then we might have to strike fine balance so discussion / debates/vichar can be equally proportionally spread across other areas/sections/topics in the forum for example- gurbani, meditation, sikh samparda etc.What you guys think? Limit to sri dasam granth discussion for once (for 7 days) in a month. I really don't want to enforce limitations on the topic so it would defeat the purpose of freedom of speech /freedom of expression / freedom of liberty on this forum.what you guys think? 0 Quote
Popular Post amardeep Posted July 30, 2015 Popular Post Report Posted July 30, 2015 Naah let them be. Its good to have a healthy open debate about these things. 4 Quote
Popular Post kdsingh80 Posted July 30, 2015 Popular Post Report Posted July 30, 2015 As long debates are in civilized manner let them have 3 Quote
CdnSikhGirl Posted July 30, 2015 Report Posted July 30, 2015 I don't think anything needs to be limited as that would send wrong message about freedom to discuss certain topics (like certain other forums) and also if members wish not to discuss these things they have the choice to just avoid those topics... Nobody is forcing them. 2 Quote
dalsingh101 Posted July 30, 2015 Report Posted July 30, 2015 I think debate/discussions are positive, but just anticipate some people turning up and playing the usual clutching their handbags to their chests aghast 'nindak' card. lolIt was all the negativity about the DG that caused me to look at it in more detail - I love it now. So that was a bit of an own goal for all the anti-DG brigade. 2 Quote
mrsingh Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 (edited) N30 Paji, whilst I think open respectful and civilised debate is good for the Panth ...We (all of us, myself included) cannot afford to take our eyes of bigger Panthic objectives that we all agree upon.Thus how we tackle the menace of drugs, alcohol, female infanticide, caste biraderi, illiteracy, cancer and poverty afflicting our Panth should be our main overall focus. But if debate can make all realise that everyone reveres Dashmesh Pita equally that is good too as hopefully that can help push us towards the Unity that we need to ensure single united Sangat Gurdwara's in every pind and locality in the West and ensuring 100% literacy globally. Edited July 31, 2015 by mrsingh 0 Quote
SikhKhoj Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 Thanks for locking the topic Neo.Attacks on AKJ and others are openly allowed on this forum because you yourself may not like them but things you do not like are censored. 0 Quote
SAadmin Posted July 31, 2015 Author Report Posted July 31, 2015 This has nothing to do with AKJ. AKJ, nirmale, taksal, sevapanthis, nihangs, udasi , 3ho all been under scrutiny via debates. Have you seen posts against DDT and other orders by mrsingh? 0 Quote
chatanga1 Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 Neo, give everyone a week to re-evaulate and open it again. 1 Quote
chatanga1 Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 Thanks for locking the topic Neo.Attacks on AKJ and others are openly allowed on this forum because you yourself may not like them but things you do not like are censored.is that what you think has been happening on this forum recently? 0 Quote
SikhKhoj Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 Not that I like AKJ but one gets away easily by attacking them on here rather than Taksal or especially the Dasam Granth. You should be impartial as an admin, Neo. 0 Quote
SAadmin Posted July 31, 2015 Author Report Posted July 31, 2015 Again , please provide proof - AKJ and Taksal. Have you seen some of the post by satkiran, mrsingh strong opinions against DDT. I also like to remind you yourself had a very strong opinion against sant gurbachan singh bhindranwale of DDT, we allowed that even as long as it was done respectfully. 0 Quote
SikhKhoj Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 True that. Why was the DG topic locked? 0 Quote
Popular Post chatanga1 Posted July 31, 2015 Popular Post Report Posted July 31, 2015 Again , please provide proof - AKJ and Taksal. Have you seen some of the post by satkiran, mrsingh strong opinions against DDT. I also like to remind you yourself had a very strong opinion against sant gurbachan singh bhindranwale of DDT, we allowed that even as long as it was done respectfully. it wasn't even doen respectfully, sikhkhoj called Sant Gurbachan Singh "gurbachana" a mockery of his name but that was allowed. 5 Quote
SAadmin Posted July 31, 2015 Author Report Posted July 31, 2015 it wasn't even doen respectfully, sikhkhoj called Sant Gurbachan Singh "gurbachana" a mockery of his name but that was allowed. Sorry we let that one slip. Will watch out for future. 0 Quote
SAadmin Posted July 31, 2015 Author Report Posted July 31, 2015 True that. Why was the DG topic locked?Back and forth between you and amardeep 0 Quote
SikhKhoj Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 (edited) Sorry we let that one slip. Will watch out for future.Karde ban Neo Sian. I don't care Edited July 31, 2015 by SikhKhoj 0 Quote
SAadmin Posted July 31, 2015 Author Report Posted July 31, 2015 I don't believe in bans. But you need to calm down swearing, talking about families. If it continues, i be straight up you be put on quality control. I have bigger responsibility on here than deal with this crap back and forth 0 Quote
SikhKhoj Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 Yeah whatever. Do takkeh de bandeh make passes on me regarding naam simran without first looking at themselves lol 0 Quote
SAadmin Posted July 31, 2015 Author Report Posted July 31, 2015 Ok Sikhkhoj you may want to take a break and calm down over the weekend and come back on here if you wish but this is really last warning before you be put on quality control. 0 Quote
SikhKhoj Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 (edited) Said nothing wrong Neo. Calm down, where is your shaanti? Edited July 31, 2015 by SikhKhoj 0 Quote
SAadmin Posted July 31, 2015 Author Report Posted July 31, 2015 All recent dasam granth/treh charitar threads are locked for now until further notice. 0 Quote
SikhKhoj Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 (edited) lol. Edited July 31, 2015 by SikhKhoj 0 Quote
mahanpaapi Posted July 31, 2015 Report Posted July 31, 2015 my humble submission is that there should not be any discussion on the authenticity Sri Dasam Granth on this site unless it is of view that is not or disputed, therefore need to be settled here, a remote possibility. from the perspective of those who believe that it is authentic and Bani of Dhan Dhan Dhan Sri Guru Gobind Singh Ji Maharaj, it is question of devotion not discussion, and devotion is at very high pedestal than freedom of whatever. mow the if sa believes that it is Maharaji's Bani (regardeess of the fact if it is nor), then questioning and bringing in doubts about Sri Dasam Granth, will create more doubts for ordinary folks. the discussion can happen on its relevance in moderns society and how it was used by puritan sikhs. for me, is unequivocally settled not because i have "historical evidence" but because those all Dargahi Mahapuraksh (including original Five Beloved) and those blessed by them have never rejected anything related to Sri Dasam Granth, and i urge those who believe in it please not do use improper method and language against those who not approve it. finally it is slippery slope, tomorrow someone will want to discuss the same issues regarding Sri Granth Sahib Ji Maharaj, then even if there is Sachkhand so on and so forth. 0 Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.